The automotive landscape in China has experienced significant evolution over the past few decades, marked by the rise of joint ventures that amalgamate diverse international automaking expertise with local knowledgeThis blend has resulted in a rich tapestry of automotive culture within the country, with joint venture vehicles often viewed as the standard-bearers of innovation, quality, and consumer accessibilityTraditionally, the perception has been that German cars excel in safety, American brands are powerful and muscular, Japanese manufacturing is synonymous with fuel efficiency, while French vehicles embody romance and artistry.

However, the recent statements from GAC Toyota during the Guangzhou Auto Show sparked a wave of discourse by proclaiming, "Joint ventures do not equate to being behind." This perspective has been interpreted by some analysts as an admission that the competitive edge of joint venture enterprises is waningThis is further highlighted by troubling news emerging from GAC Honda, which has garnered widespread attention recently due to alterations in their workforce and production outputs.

Reports circulated on December 2 indicating that GAC Honda was poised to cut 900 positions due to a reduction in productionGAC Honda quickly responded, clarifying that it was not enacting layoffs, but rather ending its agreements with labor services, aimed at adjusting its workforce to align with production needsGAC Honda assured that these fluctuations would not hinder its production lines nor its strategic advancements in electrification and automation.

Notably, while GAC Honda disclaims layoffs, the fact remains that production has indeed decreased, a trend that has been clear in historical production dataSince 2021, GAC Honda's production and sales figures have consistently dipped; for instance, in 2022, their production and sales fell by 2.45% and 4.93% respectivelyMore recently, the figures from October 2023 revealed a staggering decrease in both production and sales by over 20%. In stark contrast, GAC Toyota has also reported downturns in performance, indicating a broader issue affecting various joint venture brands under GAC Group.

The GAC Group, a well-respected enterprise in China as part of the Fortune Global 500, has long been synonymous with joint ventures, including GAC Honda and GAC Toyota, among others like GAC Mitsubishi and GAC Fiat Chrysler

Advertisements

Yet, in the last eighteen months, both GAC Mitsubishi and GAC Fiat Chrysler have faced grave challenges, including bankruptcy and restructuringThus, the declining performance of GAC Honda and GAC Toyota amidst these changes demonstrates a shift in the narrative surrounding joint venture operations — suggesting that the once lucrative model may no longer be as profitable.

As of December 5, 2023, GAC Group shares closed at 9.54 yuan, with a total market capitalization of 100.1 billion yuanThis financial backdrop follows an impressive milestone, as GAC Honda celebrated the achievement of its 10 millionth vehicle sold, a testament to its historical significance since its establishment in 1998. However, this ceremony is overshadowed by the recent decline in sales.

The Chinese automobile industry traces its roots back to 1956, when the first domestic vehicle rolled off the assembly line, marking the inception of a vibrant and competitive industryThe history of joint ventures gained momentum in 1983 with Beijing Jeep, heralding a new epoch characterized by the integration of global standards and practices into the Chinese marketThe 1990s saw a boom in joint ventures, including notable partnerships such as FAW-Volkswagen and Dongfeng PSA.

GAC Honda, established with a partnership involving GAC Group and Honda, enjoyed rapid growth, setting records for speed-to-market and innovation in the early yearsThe brand launched China’s first automotive 4S dealership and was at the forefront of introducing technology in the production processBy 2005, sales had escalated significantly, positioning GAC Honda as a vital subdivision of GAC Group.

Yet, a closer examination reveals a troubling trend in the brand's recent history, as the excitement surrounding its vehicle lineups began to waneBetween 2016 and 2020, while GAC Honda remained the top seller within GAC Group, a gradual slowdown in sales was evidentFor instance, sales growth plummeted from 10.12% in 2016 to a mere 2.65% by 2020. This sales contraction became more pronounced in 2021 when GAC Honda first recorded a drop in production and sales, which further exacerbated throughout 2022, culminating in a significant downturn in 2023.

As GAC Honda seeks to respond to these challenges, there have been indications of a strategic pivot towards electric vehicle (EV) offerings, marking a critical juncture for the brand in addressing its sales decline

Advertisements

The introduction of models like the Accord e:PHEV and the e:NP1 position GAC Honda favourably to tackle the changing landscape of consumer preferences toward greener alternatives.

However, the struggles extended beyond GAC HondaGAC Toyota also experienced setbacks, with sales declines surpassing 9%. Before the downturn, GAC Toyota had enjoyed sustained growth, with sales increasing over 20% in 2022 aloneThe urgency felt by executives in the face of suddenly changing data highlights the unpredictable nature of the market and the daunting challenges ahead for established brands.

During a recent address, GAC Toyota’s executives emphasized the notion that joint ventures represent maturity and resilience, underscoring the need for these enterprises to adapt and thrive amidst evolving market conditions, bringing forth a new phase in the automotive sector where adaptability might dictate survivalTheir comments reflect an awareness of the intense competition posed by regional brands and the rapid rise of domestic competitors in the electric vehicle sector.

In the context of these transitions, GAC Group's struggles with joint ventures resonate across the industry, as numerous foreign and domestic brands vie for market shareIt is evident from recent data published by industry associations that while many joint venture brands experience declines, Chinese indigenous brands such as GAC Aion and GAC Motor have witnessed remarkable growth, contributing substantially to the group’s revenue even as traditional joint venture operations falter under pressure.

The landscape appears to be shifting decisively, with younger, more dynamic brands capturing the interest and loyalty of the modern consumerThe failures and restructuring witnessed in GAC Mitsubishi and GAC Fiat Chrysler further represent a crisis of confidence in the traditional joint venture model, suggesting that without embracing emerging technologies and adapting to consumer desires, even well-established brands risk obsolescence.

The fate of GAC Honda and GAC Toyota will be closely monitored as they navigate this volatile environment, striving to innovate and rejuvenate their offerings

Advertisements

Advertisements

Advertisements